1. icon-arrow-left
    Find a Doctor
Caitlin Hartsgrove,  MD

Accepting New Patients

Online Booking

Caitlin Hartsgrove, MD

Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation

4.9
(62)

Female

Want to know your insurance options?

See Full List

My upcoming availability

0

About me

Caitlin Hartsgrove, MD, is a fellowship-trained physiatrist with Atlantic Medical Group. Board-certified in physical medicine and rehabilitation (PM&R) and board-eligible in brain injury medicine by the American Board of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, she believes in providing compassionate care to patients of all ages and restoring function to all following concussion and a variety of other brain injuries.


After earning her medical degree at Rutgers New Jersey Medical School, Newark, NJ, Dr. Hartsgrove completed her PM&R residency and fellowship training brain injury medicine at Rutgers New Jersey Medical School/Kessler Institute for Rehabilitation, where she was named clinical chief resident with educational track distinction and received several other honors, including the Resident Recognition Award and the Areti Award - Resident Graduation Award. She served as the Wellness Chair on the residency’s Curriculum Committee. She was also active on the Neurorehabilitation Journal Club and the Medical Student Mentorship Program.


Dr. Hartsgrove’s research included managing agitation in patients after traumatic brain injury, outcomes in hypoxic-ischemic brain injury, rehabilitation outcomes during the COVID-19 pandemic, medical students’ knowledge of Americans with Disability Act requirements, among others. She is a coauthor of articles in peer-reviewed journals and has presented multiple times at national scientific conferences. She has given Grand Rounds lectures to multiple institutions on the topic of disorders of consciousness. In addition, at the Kessler Institute, she has lectured on many topics including concussion in sports medicine, walking aids for better balance, post-traumatic seizures/epilepsy, and disorders of consciousness. Dr. Hartsgrove is a participating provider of the Atlantic Accountable Care Organization.

Areas of focus: Brian Injury Medicine, Concussions, Stroke Rehabilitation

SPECIALTIES

  • Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation

AFFILIATIONS

  • Accountable Care Organization

  • Atlantic Medical Group

  • Morristown Medical Center

  • Overlook Medical Center

Where to see me

Insurance

Please contact the practice to confirm your health plan is accepted.

  • Aetna

  • Aetna Better Health

  • AHS PPO

  • Amerihealth

  • Amerihealth Caritas

  • Brighton Create

  • Brighton Healthplan Solutions

  • Centivo

  • Cigna

  • ClaimDoc LLC

  • Education & Experience

    TRAINING

    Rutgers New Jersey Medical School

    Medical School

    Rutgers New Jersey Medical School

    Internship

    Kessler Institute for Rehabilitation

    Residency

    BOARD CERTIFICATIONS

    Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation

    American Board of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation

    Patient Reviews

    OVERALL RATING

    4.9

    (62 ratings)
    25 reviews
    • 5.0
      Jun 21, 2026
      I would recommend Dr. Hartsgrove for her knowledge, compassion & kindness. She always responds to all messages and has called me with reports and talking about treatments.
    • 5.0
      Jun 21, 2026
      Dr. Hartsgrove is very kind and explains everything. She is trying to help my chronic headaches and has explored all possible treatments.
    • 5.0
      Jun 21, 2026
      Doctor Caitlin takes time to explain ,never rushed, always helpful great doctor
    • 5.0
      Jun 18, 2026
      Listened to my concerns about side effect of medications - gave lower dose. (Called back ater 1 week of med as side effect was to hard to manage. She responded back in a timely manner and changed the medication immediately).
    • 5.0
      Jun 13, 2026
      Dr. Hartgrove's attention, knowledgeable and care is excellent.